CO129-010 - Sir Henry Pottinger - 1843 — Page 537

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

and which receipt will free you from any responsibility on their account.

I remain,

(Signed) Richard Moosnam

The Honourable,

Sir,

Major Caine,

Chief Magistrate,


Victoria, 31st October, 1841.

I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your letters No. 211 & 262 of the 28th Instant.

I am to acquaint you that His Excellency the Governor desires me to state that he entirely concurs in your opinion as to the guilt of Le Aman; that had the case been sooner referred to him, His Excellency would not have had any hesitation in sentencing him to at least two years' hard labour, for as a Servant of Government it must be remembered, that he was guilty in a tenfold degree. This, however, cannot now be remedied.

I cannot better convey to you His Excellency's opinion as to the culpability of Le Aman than by quoting his own words: "I take this opportunity to observe that I consider accused persons being allowed to prove alibis by the testimony of abandoned women is altogether inadmissible. Amongst all classes of Chinese there seems to me to be a total absence of veracity, or any moral feeling, and in this case, had I been the presiding Magistrate, and Le Aman had not been able to prove, by circumstantial evidence (always the best in China), that he was absent with the leave, and with the knowledge of his superiors and lawfully...

Edit History

2026-05-16 23:40:31 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
and which receipt will free you from any responsibility on their account. I remain, (Signed) Richard Moosnam The Honourable, Sir, Major Caine, Chief Magistrate, Victoria, 31st October, 1841. I have the honour to acknowledge the receipt of your letters No. 211 & 262 of the 28th Instant. I am to acquaint you that His Excellency the Governor desires me to state that he entirely concurs in your opinion as to the guilt of Le Aman; that had the case been sooner referred to him, His Excellency would not have had any hesitation in sentencing him to at least two years' hard labour, for as a Servant of Government it must be remembered, that he was guilty in a tenfold degree. This, however, cannot now be remedied. I cannot better convey to you His Excellency's opinion as to the culpability of Le Aman than by quoting his own words: "I take this opportunity to observe that I consider accused persons being allowed to prove alibis by the testimony of abandoned women is altogether inadmissible. Amongst all classes of Chinese there seems to me to be a total absence of veracity, or any moral feeling, and in this case, had I been the presiding Magistrate, and Le Aman had not been able to prove, by circumstantial evidence (always the best in China), that he was absent with the leave, and with the knowledge of his superiors and lawfully...
Baseline (Original)
and which receipt will, free you, from. any responsibility on their account. Iremain. Ve (Signed) Richard Moosnam The Honmable, Sir.. Major Caine. Chief . Magistrate, - Victoria, 312th October, 18413. I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your letters N211 + 262 of the 28th Instant. me to His Excellency the Governor, derivet that he entirely. say, that he concurs in. Your opinion as to the quilt and the 1 Le Aman; that had the case been sooner. referred to him. His Excelleney would to hesitation in not have had any Sentencing him at least two years, A Gb. hard hard Labour, for... · as a Servant of T of 532 Government it must be remembered, that he tv as quitty in 14 : tenfold degree this His however, cannot new be remedied_ I cannot better convey to You Excellency's opinion as to the culpability of Muong toke than. by quoting his own words : " I take this opportunity to observe. " that I consider. accused persons being allowed - alibis by the testimony of "to prove. "Abandoned. Women is altogether.. " inadmissible _ Amongst all classes of "Chinese there seems to me to be a total. " absence of veracity, or any moral feeling, and in this case, had I been the presiding "Magistrate, and Yaong Aebo had not been "able to prove, by prove, by Circumstantial. "Evidence. (always the best in Chinx), that absent with the leave, and The was "Knowledge of his superiors and lawfully
2026-05-16 23:40:31 · Baseline
View content

and which receipt will, free you, from. any responsibility on their account.

Iremain. Ve

(Signed) Richard Moosnam

The Honmable,

Sir..

Major Caine.

Chief . Magistrate,

-

Victoria, 312th October, 18413.

I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your letters N211 + 262 of

the 28th Instant.

me to

His Excellency the Governor, derivet

that he entirely. say, that he

concurs in.

Your opinion as to the quilt

and the

1 Le Aman; that had the case been sooner. referred to him. His Excelleney would

to

hesitation in

not have had any Sentencing him at least two years,

A

N® Gb.

hard

hard Labour, for...

· as a Servant of

T

of

532

Government it must be remembered, that

he

tv as

quitty

in

14

:

tenfold degree this

His

however, cannot new be remedied_

I cannot better convey to You Excellency's opinion as to the culpability of Muong toke than. by quoting his own words : " I take this opportunity to observe. " that I consider. accused persons being allowed - alibis by the testimony of

"to prove.

"Abandoned. Women is

altogether..

" inadmissible _ Amongst all classes of

"Chinese there

seems to

me

to be a total.

" absence of veracity, or any moral feeling, and in this case, had I been the presiding "Magistrate, and Yaong Aebo had not been "able to prove, by

prove, by Circumstantial.

"Evidence. (always the best in Chinx), that

absent with the leave, and

The

was

"Knowledge of his superiors and

lawfully

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.